HomeПутешествияRelated VideosMore From: Bloomberg

How New York Got Its Skyline

11045 ratings | 548303 views
Why do so many of New York's older skyscrapers have a similar design? The answer can be traced back to a monumental 1916 zoning law, which established “setback” requirements for buildings above a certain height. In the heart of the Financial District, the Equitable Building, a historic skyscraper that predates the law, remains a symbol of the excesses of the pre-zoning era. Video by Raymond Schillinger Camera: Brian Schildhorn Additional Production: Ren Potts, Jordan Oplinger, Maya Greene Graphics: Christian Capestany Special thanks to: Silverstein Properties Carol Willis - Founder, Director, and Curator of The Skyscraper Museum New York City Department of City Planning Archival Photographs from Getty Images, POND5 #NYC #history #architecture
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (287)
Ashley Zheng (24 days ago)
Zoning laws can sometimes be total bullshit
Geff Stone (1 month ago)
its funny how scared they were back then haha
wumingkkk (2 months ago)
Thanks for the infor Bloomberg. I just came back from NYC and thought it was trying to be unique but you have enlightened me. The setback has accidentally made the city so unique and I find it pleasant looking.
Typhoon792 (2 months ago)
Yeah, unfortunately didn't help any. Still the most oppressive skyline in the world, particularly when actually looking from the bottom (people live inside it, not fly around it, how it's always shown). Don't how "distinct" it is, but the architecture certainly isn't much of anything to behold, consisting mostly of ugly grey boxes (viewed from any angle). Walking through most any street in NYC, having the height pushed back doesn't help at all in actually seeing past the buildings. Sky-to-cement wall ratio is still about 20:1.
ninny65 (2 months ago)
A rare case of government regulation being effective
Hose Clamp (3 months ago)
I wonder how many of those buildings will survive one of these new hurricanes that we're starting to deal with.
Commentator541 (3 months ago)
Yet we have the ugly At&t building
LadyAmanita (3 months ago)
You can see this even in skyscrapers built during the Mad Men era- the 50's into the early 60's. Here's some notable examples- 270 Park Avenue and 1285 6th avenue (1960), 1290 6th Avenue (1963) and 277 Park Avenue (1964). However, architectural fashion had changed- clients wanted sleek, modern towers instead of the "frozen fountain" look popular during the Art Deco era. So architects moved most of the setbacks to the sides and backs of the buildings, giving them the appearance of having tails, after a fashion. People notice the tall and sleek tower fronting the avenue, but often don't see that there's a whole tail section happening too, which often contains a sizeable chunk of floor space. 1290 6th Avenue's got the most complicated arrangement of setbacks of any of these towers.
Derpster (3 months ago)
Old european buildings are the opposite. The higher you go, the wider they get.
News Moto (3 months ago)
Well produced film! Keep it up!
Fresh Haus (3 months ago)
This is incentive for lot mergers because you have to create a larger lot area to allow a building to be taller. It also further concentrates wealth because people with smaller lots face more limitations.
Angelchildxx (3 months ago)
Actually with the fReedom tower the skyline of NY have dramatically worsened. It was so WAY BETTER with the twin towers that those fucking (dead) animals have took it down.
MegasAlexandru (3 months ago)
Ok, but what about the twin towers back then? They had straight walls from the bottom to the top
cvt cvt (3 months ago)
New Yorkers are all about controlling others.
Eric Judkins-van buren (3 months ago)
It is georgous, especially on the inside. I have actually been in it .
EJ Ioane (3 months ago)
wow , I visited Manhattan from Australia a few months ago and I looked back at the photos I took from the empire state building roof top and I had always notice how the older sky scrappers were shaped distinctively from the newer sky scrapers and now I found the answer. NYC is such a fascinating place and I look forward to returning there some time soon and I want to see a college marching band too.
silver70 (3 months ago)
Love learning new things!
EinChris75 (3 months ago)
That time when laws balanced all sides of requirements...
TheSpacecraftX (3 months ago)
Isn't it just a generic skyscraper fest?
starrychloe (3 months ago)
Houston and Grafton, New Hampshire have no zoning laws.
Viniso (3 months ago)
The Twin Towers didn't seem to respect this law.
Pyro Paragon (3 months ago)
They were set far from the street in a plaza
BulbousBumbo376 (3 months ago)
They hit the sky limit
AiSard (3 months ago)
Should have covered Air Rights as well. The tug and pull between developers and regulations.
Beacon of Wierd (3 months ago)
Ah, regulations at it's finest :) I mean, FUCK REGULATIONS!! I BUILD WHAT I WANT! PUNY ROAD, SAY HELLO TO A SOLID RECTANGLE OF STEEL!!!
Link (3 months ago)
What is the music????
Ted Morris (3 months ago)
And then we got the Twin Towers, jutting upwards and not inwards, long and slender and majestic. Man those were great buildings.
Ted Morris (3 months ago)
Indeed, in fact I know several native New Yorkers who hated the original WTC complex, but now you have the freedom tower, which just doesn't have anything close to as powerful an imprint on the skyline. Unfortunately we can never have the twin towers back.
godofthisshit (3 months ago)
Ted Morris People originally thought they were ugly. I guess they were as individual buildings but together they were amazing. Freedom tower dropped the ball.
zachary hebert (3 months ago)
f u bloomberg
Alexander Martin (3 months ago)
So its this laws fault I can't work, shop, live, in one mega skyscraper.
Pyro Paragon (3 months ago)
Yep
Celina K (3 months ago)
2:05 nice 3:20 not nice It's why you don't see the european tradition of having small boutiques and apartments above them.
Katie Lee (2 months ago)
Celina K what are you talking about there’s apartments above stores and restaurants all over the city
Jacob Chap (3 months ago)
Huh. Neat.
Norman J. Murk (3 months ago)
I'm a builder and that's one of the coolest things I've learned yet, thanks for that!
ChrisGeez (3 months ago)
I thought this vid would discuss how differences in the depth and size of the bedrock across Manhattan limits how tall buildings can be because of varying weight-bearing limits.
osriodore (3 months ago)
Otis always made the best elevators
chicee123 (3 months ago)
Chicago's got the best skyline.
Clems First (3 months ago)
Did I hear estate ? Don't worry... It's free real estate.
It has a disgusting sky line, look at that concrete jungle? No wonder European nations dont want their cities to look like American concrete jungles, truly disgusting. Why in any ones mind would you want to visit New York? There is nothing there and that applies to the US as a whole. Personally i would only go to LA or whatever for the gun range and that is it. History is so small i would best go to Switzerland to get more history. Skyline is made of concrete, horrible
shng sam (3 months ago)
but why is it in shape of "H" when trying to maximize space, wouldn't building it in a square shape have more space? ( the 2 indent in the H will be used )
shng sam (3 months ago)
ooh, this makes sense. building it in H will maximize number of windows
The Danger (3 months ago)
shng sam A square wouldn't have an outside view and for an office it's a bad thing
Oliver Heady (3 months ago)
Wow, awesome video!
Mastro (3 months ago)
Mind. Blown.
Clif Dickens (3 months ago)
Such a well-crafted video that finds the sweet spot between informative and engaging.
pavan patel (3 months ago)
Interesting!
Scott Anderson (3 months ago)
Michael Bloomberg is a ninny
stenbak88 (3 months ago)
Government regulation only hurts
cold_vanilla_soy_latte (3 months ago)
Not only the people owning a building and working in it are affected by its height, but also other inhabitants of a city. To protect their interests (sunlight, desirable landscape, et cetera) it is very reasonable to enforce regulations.
Mike Richard (3 months ago)
stenbak88 is wrong. REGULATION SAVES LIVES.
Michael King (3 months ago)
Housing in NYC and DC is expensive because of zoning laws
Michael King (3 months ago)
Muh real estate values
Michael King (3 months ago)
How is it too big?
Mike Richard (3 months ago)
Michael King , back then : STEEL FRAMES WERE EXPENSIVE AND RARE. EVEN MORE-SO THAN NOW.
Tony13000000 (3 months ago)
It isn't now but back then it was huge, and with the financial districts narrow streets it cast a shadow over everything
Michael King (3 months ago)
Fuck zoning laws
Tommy Amato (3 months ago)
Very weird how the thing you learn your first week in architecture school can become a super interesting video to so many. Great video by Bloomberg, editing and graphics were top notch.
Masood Shaikh (3 months ago)
Is there an exception to that rule? I notice the UN building (at 4:00) isn't built in that style.. and it's pretty broad too. Although it's in a less dense area, there's a similar older building (at 3:39) which is also in an open area, but has the stepped design. Any thoughts?
Michael King (3 months ago)
It has a setback
X X (3 months ago)
very interesting
I am Jobu (3 months ago)
So the empire state building was just an architect's idea of trolling the zoning law
Brad the Pitts (3 months ago)
Born & raised - I did NOT know this.
noreworks (3 months ago)
I've seen so many fact videos in youtube, it's really rare to see something that's actually never been discussed before 👍🏻
Anderson Klein (3 months ago)
Basically all was going good until the cronies had to regulate to keep rent prices high. Thanks to zoning laws nowadays you have to commute by car for hours or pay stupendous amounts of rent to live downtown, all because someone thought it was a good idea to restrict where apartment complexes and offices can be built. Now people life far from their work which wastes billions of commute hours nationwide and hurts the environment.
nothing (2 months ago)
I think zoning is only good when it's used to keep out dangerous industrials.
EpicKaiserTom (3 months ago)
Not all of it was zoning laws, though it certainly didn't help. I would say most of that specific problem was the trillions we spent in subsidizing the automobile through our extensive road and highway system, which subsidized suburban sprawl as a result.
Mariela Band (3 months ago)
Could this please be 20 minutes longer?
Pradeep Kalaimaran (3 months ago)
The amount of work that has gone into this four minute long video is substantial. So pleasing to watch. You made it look so simple and perhaps, that's the sign of excellent content. Thanks! Keep going!
eVCephei (3 months ago)
wow
jeremyscharlack (3 months ago)
Hugh Ferriss, an architectural illustrator, did some very cool drawings of how buildings could look with the 1916 zoning not long after the law was passed. An example (google yields a few more): https://www.skyscraper.org/EXHIBITIONS/FUTURE_CITY/NEW_YORK_MODERN/walkthrough_1916.php
J.Jarvis (3 months ago)
I love old buildings that are made with stone. Amazing work.
sarcasmo57 (3 months ago)
Kind of makes me feel like building a building.
William Henley (3 months ago)
First you would need to build on your knowledge of building buildings in order to build a building
Kyle Li (3 months ago)
I cant look at them in any different way now... oh boy
Tom H. (3 months ago)
New York is the only city with a really good, memorable skyline. All others have skylines that are undistinctive or to some extent gimmicky.
Tom H. (2 months ago)
iTechTips, US Bank Tower is exactly what I mean by gimmicky. Like Dallas, San Francisco, Atlanta, other cities with individually beautiful bldgs but no other city has a skyline that appears to rise out of the water because of the way Manhattan is a flat narrow island.
Robert (2 months ago)
Tom H. So does Los Angeles, the US Bank Tower
Typhoon792 (2 months ago)
That's simply because of New York's geography and zoning, not because of its architecture.
RaymondHng (3 months ago)
The Transmerica Pyramid (along with the Mt. Sutro transmission tower) has been making the San Francisco skyline distinctive since the '70s. The newly built Salesforce tower surpassed it as the tallest building in the city.
EG:UK (3 months ago)
I got a Bentley advert. I bet they paid loads for that lol. I'm never going to be able to afford a Bently. They don't need to advertise. The name is enough.
EG:UK (3 months ago)
Spelling mistake is a spelling mistake is a spelling mistake
Clerisvaldo Nogueira (3 months ago)
Dude it's spelled Bentley
SillySOSedge (3 months ago)
If the name is enough, then why can't you spell it?
lee Roberts (3 months ago)
You got a bemyly ad...I got a cat food commerical.
kairon156 (3 months ago)
I have noticed NewYork's buildings went inword as it went up but I never knew it was because of zoning laws. Also, Some places have laws for having so much ground area wrather it's parks or what ever around a tower.
Ramkumar Yadav (3 months ago)
Dutpur
Erick Lopez (4 months ago)
The City of Los Angeles was actually the first to regulate land use going back to 1904. https://recode.la/sites/default/files/file_attachments/basic_page/OrdNo9774-ResidentialDistricts%28July%2025%201904%29.pdf
Luelzia Graca (4 months ago)
I wish I could go NYC
MLuisendy Fernandez (4 months ago)
Am I the only one who think that 432 park ave look slightly like the World Trade Center twin towers
Guillaume Duteaud (5 months ago)
Hey! Could you link to the article quoted in the video regarding evil effects? Can’t find it on my own. Thanks!
Kieran Jansz (6 months ago)
I thought this was about the Nissan GT-R
Augus Javed (6 months ago)
432 Bark Ave......in Staten Island....a building in the shape of a 775 foot tall beagle....to honor this fine hound of renown🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎉🎉🎉
Augus Javed (6 months ago)
same ole, same ole....dull, lifeless,static bland building projects...glass curtain wall....too boring.......we need a new approach....a new theme and style...I new mind set....since the beginning of skyscrapers it has always been to honor business and industry....or religion.... ...Dullsville Merghatroyd....... How about honoring the women and females of the world....the women who bore us ..... don't they deserve an honor , and statement in architecture ???....to do them proud?? I give you proudly 👉👉👉👉 One Ovary Place a 167 floor...2154 foot tall building in the shape of an ovary.....located near Sutton Place in new York. ......mixed use. ..maternity hospital residential,business,retail,and entertainment.... it's sure to raise some discussion💁💁💁💁
matt O (6 months ago)
why is a building called a building if it is already built?
hifijohn (2 months ago)
And why do we have hot water heater??? Why do we need to heat hot water???
2012isRonPaul (2 months ago)
its part of the grammar school teachers coverup to fuck u up during their retarded grammar tests because you cant write that you are building a building
Commentator541 (3 months ago)
matt O it's a noun, not a verb
IgorD (3 months ago)
Because it is forever in a process of building. Next time you walk into one - patch a hole in a wall or nail a step, buddy! .. but don't point a finger at me when they catch you drawing a bigger dick on a renaissance painting at your local museum.
Anon B (3 months ago)
Building has two fairly distinct meanings as a noun, if you think about it: * Something already constructed - "it's one of the ugliest buildings in the city". * The process of constructing something - "the building of the pyramids took many years". (There are a few other meanings of "building" - as in adding to something, or gaining sympathy, but that's for another discussion.)
Jessica Anderson (6 months ago)
right on
monobg antonina (6 months ago)
What about all the all glass and steel more modern skyscrapers that just start and continue in a straight line to the top? Like the WTC for example?
Allen Zhang (6 months ago)
Do one on Chicago!
Rose Bubbles (6 months ago)
Dubai "Our height limit is bloody space"
Takyi Kobbie (6 months ago)
Wow New York in 1960 looks better than my country
cloud ix (6 months ago)
Only took them 25 years #godzilla
Awesome Me (6 months ago)
wait this is not vox?
Alex (3 months ago)
Awesome Me vox is garbage
North Royalton (6 months ago)
9/11
Luc Laan (6 months ago)
How about 9/11?
MrGriff305 (6 months ago)
the old twin towers sort of ignored setbacks
Clerisvaldo Nogueira (3 months ago)
+Mike Richard they didn't fell because of their height, they fell because some assholes in the middle East wanted to prove a point
Mike Richard (3 months ago)
MrGriff305 , imagine how many lives would have been saved if they just complied with the old law !
MrGriff305 (6 months ago)
Bloomberg .. That makes sense. I think the vertical faces of the twins contributed to their skyline prominence. For example... they always looked much bigger than the Empire State Building from far away. This was an interesting video. Thank you!
Bloomberg (6 months ago)
Thanks for your comment! The original World Trade Center towers (which were built after the updated 1961 Zoning Resolution) were built on a large, multi-block plaza. This meant the towers were technically "set back" from the street far enough to be built to their record-setting heights without a visible setback in the structure.
Shaylah M. (6 months ago)
So interesting!!!!!$
Nathan Schaefer (6 months ago)
Oh wow, this is actually really fascinating
Tristan Möller (6 months ago)
Wow. Learned something, nice video. Glad to see that the Zoning Resolution was very well thought out and worked out for the city. Yeah, here in Europe skyscrapers were proposed in some cities in Germany (of course we barely have need for them), but in many cases we also don’t want them.
John Smith (7 months ago)
9/11
AcidOllie (7 months ago)
I must be getting old because I found this absolutely fascinating.
A Cote (3 months ago)
+DGRIFF! Yeah I love interior design and architecture, It's so intriguing to see what people come up with out of endless possibilities to live in
DGRIFF! (3 months ago)
+A Cote You are either an old soul or are on the spectrum. Either way, much respect!
Martim Xavier (3 months ago)
17 years old, don't give a damn about architecture, but still love this
FreeriderNation (3 months ago)
21yo construction engineer student. Found this super fascinating.
Lifeisgood72 (3 months ago)
I’m 15 and been obsessed with architecture since I was 13
Sam Fox (7 months ago)
Is the One World Trade Center an exception to this code?
Julian Collot (7 months ago)
Death to zoning laws!
WeedTaco (7 months ago)
Speed Levich explained this to me once while on a walk
Andrew Weizer (7 months ago)
I pass that building all the time never noticed hot beautiful it is until now
ShadowWhelp (7 months ago)
Honestly just always assumed buildings were built that way for stability.
Jaiden the King! (1 month ago)
Im the thousandth like
Gradius (3 months ago)
They also look much more interesting so it's a win all round really.
Harm (3 months ago)
such building shapes actually are more stable, so you aren’t entirely wrong
trevvor philip (3 months ago)
i thought it was for wind resistance
J (3 months ago)
yeah like a pyramid
Bernadette (7 months ago)
And now I work in this building. Very cool
Bella Umbrellla (7 months ago)
Everything is obscenely large and obnoxiously loud here in the city...but it's home for now, we are gucci💕💕💕
Harley Pearce (7 months ago)
Historically forget suburban implement curtain say before trade volunteer survivor goal possess.
Generic Name (3 months ago)
What the fuck did I just read?
Mark Q (7 months ago)
The original skyscraper NIMBY's. We've been fighting a hard battle with them ever since.
Ben (7 months ago)
omg govt works.
Dodo Shade (7 months ago)
thx . this was informative and interesting.
BHRxRACER (7 months ago)
is that the guy that does wendover productions?
Michael King (3 months ago)
Sounds similar but no
RWB 3vil (7 months ago)
The guy narrating sounds like Otocon from the MGS series

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.